Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You’ve got a buyer circling. Maybe a hedge fund, maybe a strategic, maybe the competitor down the street. Your CPA and your attorney walk you through the standard playbook and an ESOP either never comes up or gets dismissed as an employee benefit, not a real exit. Andre Schnabl came on the show because that’s exactly the situation his first ESOP client was sitting in. A movie production owner in Atlanta. Mid-60s. Term sheet from a hedge fund in the Midwest. Andre and his partner Todd ran the ESOP numbers against that term sheet side by side, assumed the same valuation, and the ESOP outcome was dramatically better for the seller because of how the structure and the tax code treat it. We got into the mechanics: how the trust is funded, why the senior lender writes the check, what the seller note actually does, how warrants give you a market yield on the paper you carry, and the 1042 election that can wipe out capital gains. We also got into what an ESOP isn’t for. A seller who wants 100% cash today and the keys on the table. An early-stage company that needs every dollar to grow. Honest trade-offs on both sides.
Watch on YouTube
## Top 10 Takeaways- ESOPs are sold to owners as an employee benefit. They’re actually one of the most tax-efficient exit structures around.
- Price the ESOP at the same number as your strategic offer. Structure and tax differences alone change the seller’s economics.
- The trust buys with money it doesn’t have. A lender carries the senior debt and you carry the seller note.
- Your seller note isn’t dead money. Warrants on the note give you a market yield on what you finance.
- You don’t lose control on day one. The selling shareholders appoint the board and run the business until paid out.
- Under a 1042 election, your capital gains on the exit can be deferred and potentially eliminated entirely.
- The operating company repays bank debt and the seller note with pre-tax dollars under the ESOP structure.
- A profitable ESOP-owned business can become a zero-tax entity. That’s not a loophole. That’s the structure working.
- An ESOP-owned acquirer can offer target sellers the same 1042 benefit. That becomes real negotiating leverage on price.
- ESOPs don’t work for everyone. Early-stage growth, sub-15-employee shops, and all-cash-at-close sellers should pick a different door.
Sound Bites
“Even the largest of accounting and legal firms are not particularly well informed about ESOPs and don’t think of them as a natural strategic exit tool for their business clients.” (@TBD) — Andre Schnabl
“Because of the structural differences and the tax efficiency afforded these transactions, the end result financially was far more compelling for the selling shareholder using the ESOP.” (@TBD) — Andre Schnabl
“The selling shareholders continue to control the business. They are not removing control and providing the trust with the ability to run that business. Nothing has happened from a control perspective until the selling shareholders are long gone.” (@TBD) — Andre Schnabl
“The selling shareholders can structure the transaction in such a way that they don’t have to pay capital gains on the exit.” (@TBD) — Andre Schnabl
About This Episode
Andre Schnabl is a CPA and co-founder of Tenor Capital Partners, an ESOP advisory firm. He spent his career at Grant Thornton, eventually as managing partner in his region, before retiring in 2012 and getting pulled into the ESOP world by way of a movie production client’s exit. He partners with Todd Butler, an ESOP specialist, and at the time of this conversation had closed over a dozen ESOP transactions in 24 months. He brings the technician’s view on a structure that most accounting and legal firms dismiss as an employee benefit rather than the strategic exit tool it actually is.
Resources Mentioned
- Tenor Capital Partners — Andre’s ESOP advisory firm. — tenorcap.com
- Andre Schnabl direct email — andre@tenorcap.com
- Andre Schnabl phone — 404-372-2759
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 1 — Ownership Goals — The exit you pick is downstream of what you actually want from ownership
Concepts referenced:
- Enterprise Value vs. Equity Value — The ESOP transaction sits on top of a valuation that needs both lenses
- Normalized EBITDA — The earnings number the bank is lending against in a leveraged ESOP