Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You’re staring at the next chapter and every option feels like a trade-off you don’t want to make. Sell to a strategic and your team gets gutted by the consolidator’s spreadsheet. Sell to PE and you’re working for someone else inside 18 months. Hand it to family and you’re still on the personal guarantee. The ESOP keeps getting pitched to you and you can’t tell if it’s the cleanest answer or the most complicated one in the room. I sat down with Roy Waterhouse, president of Hopkins Printing in Columbus. His father-in-law Jim founded the company in 1974, took it to market through an intermediary, walked away from a signed deal with a consolidator on a Friday, and closed an ESOP six weeks later. Thirteen years in, Hopkins grew from 50 people and $6M to 100 people and $19M, ran the deal as a 100% seller note, and Jim still works three days a week on his terms. Roy and I got into what an ESOP actually solves, what it doesn’t (it’s not a quick exit), how the board and trustee actually work, why ownership mindset compounds over a decade and not a quarter, and the retiring truck driver who said the ESOP changed his life.
Watch on YouTube
## Top 10 Takeaways- An ESOP doesn’t change how the business runs day to day. It only changes who owns it.
- If you want a fast, clean exit with the door closed behind you, an ESOP is the wrong tool.
- You can’t flip a switch and create an ownership mindset. It compounds over years of seeing real checks.
- Owners who solved problems through perks instead of distributions will hate the ESOP discipline.
- A 100% seller note plus the tax savings can fund most of the buyout without bank pressure.
- The trustee is a fiduciary, not an operator. They step in only if shareholders are being harmed.
- Your recruiting story changes the day employees can retire with a check, not just a paycheck.
- Culture becomes peer pressure when nine teammates feel the tenth dragging the share price.
- The ESOP fits best when the seller wants control of the transition, not the exit door.
- A sustainable, healthy business is the precondition for every exit option you actually want.
Sound Bites
“An ESOP sale is not as lucrative as a financial sale, but it allows you a lot of other benefits.” (@TBD) — Roy Waterhouse
“I don’t think you can flip the switch one day and have an ESOP mentality.” (@TBD) — Roy Waterhouse
“If your stakeholders want their cash and need to go somewhere quickly, it’s not a good option. But most people that spend 30, 40 years building something want to see it long-term succeed.” (@TBD) — Roy Waterhouse
“It’s the false perception that an ESOP then has a hundred bosses instead of a hundred employees.” (@TBD) — Roy Waterhouse
“We had a truck driver retire about a year ago. At his retirement party he made a speech and said, the ESOP changed my life. It allows me to be able to retire.” (@TBD) — Roy Waterhouse
About This Episode
Roy Waterhouse is the president of Hopkins Printing, a regional commercial printing company in Columbus, Ohio. He joined the family business 30 years ago, three weeks before marrying into it. His father-in-law Jim founded the company in 1974 out of his basement and grew it to 50 employees and $6M in revenue. Thirteen years after the ESOP closed in 2007, the company is at 100 employees and $19M. Roy is one of the rare voices on the show who can speak to what an ESOP looks like from the next generation’s chair, not the founder’s: managing the culture transition, working with the board and trustee, and running a real business through a recession and a pandemic with employees who own the outcome.
Resources Mentioned
- Hopkins Printing — Roy’s company. — hopkinsprinting.com
- Roy Waterhouse on LinkedIn — Where Ryan originally found Roy’s ESOP anniversary post.
- National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO) — Roy’s recommended starting point for owners exploring ESOPs.
- Tim Yocum — Local ESOP advisor in Columbus who structured the Hopkins deal.
- Jack Stack — Change the Game — Referenced on closing the inequality gap through ownership.
- Carl Allen — Previous Ryan podcast guest, cited on first-generation founder data and culture-over-money sale decisions.
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 8 — Executive Compensation — ESOP as a long-term ownership vehicle for employees
- Module 9 — Operator Transition — The seller’s transition out of the operator seat without leaving the business
Milestones:
- Milestone 24 — Long-Term Value Plan — Where the ESOP question actually lives in the roadmap
- Milestone 25 — Operator Transition Plan — Jim’s three-days-a-week transition is the case study
- Milestone 13 — Strategic Plan — The quarterly KPI cadence Roy runs with the employee-owners
Concepts referenced:
- Sustainable Financials — The precondition for the ESOP to work at all
- Distributable Cash — What the tax savings free up to service the seller note
- Normalized EBITDA — One of the inputs to the annual ESOP valuation
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — Why “I want out” owners can’t actually use an ESOP