Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You’re about to hire the heavy hitter who can finally take this company from $1M of EBITDA to $2M. They walk in wanting a big salary, an annual bonus, and real equity. You panic. You either hand over 10% of what you’ve already built, or you slap together a plan loaded with insurance that nobody actually understands. Your CPA doesn’t design these. The insurance guy will sell you a product. Nobody’s sitting at the chart with you. I brought Craig Rutledge from VisionLink on because he showed me a third path: reward the future value growth, not the value you already created. We got into why the right plan is one philosophy with two performance periods, how to build a phantom equity plan off EBITDA times a multiple minus debt plus cash, why setting a conservative par value below market protects both sides at exit, and how to layer awards over time so the plan pays for itself. Real numbers throughout: $5M par value today, 10% of the appreciation, a $12M target. The plan funds the value it creates.
Watch on YouTube
## Top 10 Takeaways- One plan, two performance periods: annual profits drive short-term, Enterprise Value growth drives long-term.
- Don’t share what you already built. Share the appreciation your hire helps create.
- Set a conservative multiple in the plan. Below market value, never above it.
- EBITDA times a multiple minus debt plus cash. The formula is boring on purpose.
- Phantom stock is a value-tracking compensation plan, not equity. You settle in cash.
- Over-engineering kills bonus plans. Define the result. Don’t try to manipulate behavior.
- Don’t grant all the shares at once. Layer awards yearly with new starting values.
- Fund the liability. Naked phantom stock on your balance sheet quietly destroys company value.
- Vesting means it’s theirs if they leave. Decide whether you’re willing to write that check.
- Communication is the plan. If your executive can’t see what they’ve earned, the plan failed.
Sound Bites
“How does this business create value? And then ultimately you can develop plans that share that value.” (@00:13:03) — Craig Rutledge
“Our philosophy is that there is one plan with two performance periods.” (@00:26:20) — Craig Rutledge
“The perfect formula for these plans is EBITDA times a multiple, minus debt, plus cash. Pretty common valuation metric for the plan.” (@00:30:17) — Craig Rutledge
“If the owners haven’t shifted their mindset towards focusing on value creation, you’re constantly going to be looking at what I’m giving up. It’s the scarcity mentality versus the abundance mentality.” (@00:37:26) — Ryan Tansom
“In theory if we’ve got our formula value, conservative to the market value, and we based it on EBITDA, I should have the value to pay that person.” (@00:46:00) — Craig Rutledge
About This Episode
Craig Rutledge is a Partner at The VisionLink Advisory Group, a boutique compensation consulting firm founded in 1996 that specializes in helping owner-operators turn pay strategy into a value-creation engine. Craig has spent 20+ years building short- and long-term incentive plans and executive benefit programs, and runs the funding analysis on VisionLink’s long-term plans. He came out of the financial services and insurance world, which is what makes his perspective distinct: he builds comp plans off the financials, not off an insurance product. This conversation sits squarely in Module 8 — Executive Compensation territory and walks through the mechanics most owners have never seen done right.
Resources Mentioned
- VisionLink Advisory Group — Craig’s firm. — visionlinkadvisors.com
- Phantom Stock Online — VisionLink’s wiki-style resource with sample plan builder, white papers, and free educational material on phantom stock plans. — phantomstockonline.com
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 8 — Executive Compensation — The home base for everything in this episode: comp philosophy, STI, and LTV design
- Module 7 — Leadership Team — Who you’re hiring drives what plan you actually need
Milestones inside Executive Compensation:
- Milestone 22 — Company Bonus Pool — The pool funding source that feeds the annual plan
- Milestone 23 — Short-Term Incentive Plan — Threshold, target, uncapped upside, dual metric (revenue + profit)
- Milestone 24 — Long-Term Value Plan — Phantom stock, SARs, vesting, formula value, triggering events
Concepts referenced:
- Normalized EBITDA — “Plan EBITDA” with add-backs and shareholder comp normalized
- The Multiple & WACC — Why the plan multiple sits below the market multiple
- Three Lenses of Value — Intrinsic (DCF) vs. transaction value, and why phantom plans convert at sale
- Value Gap — The appreciation between today’s par value and the future target
- Three-Statement Model — Where the liability accrues and the expense hits earnings each year