Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You stare at your business and you can’t decide if it’s worth what you hope, what your buddy at the country club claimed his was worth, or some number a banker would actually write a check for. The truth is, none of those are the right anchor. The right anchor is the cash flow the business produces on a standalone basis and the risk wrapped around that cash flow. That’s intrinsic value, and it’s the number you can actually move while you still own the thing. I had David Diehl, CEO of Prairie Capital Advisors, back for his third time on the show, and we got into how a financial buyer actually prices a privately held company. Why the capital stack (senior debt, sub debt, equity) puts a ceiling on what anyone can rationally pay. Why the rear-view mirror is a sanity check, not a valuation. How risk reduction (management bench, diversification, clean financials) is the lever that compresses the discount rate and expands the multiple. And the line that landed for me: you can’t see the future, but you can show your deliberate intent to produce a specific result. That’s the story the buyer is buying.
Watch on YouTube
## Top 10 Takeaways- You’re not selling the past. You’re selling the future cash flow stream, and the buyer is pricing the risk around it.
- Intrinsic value strips out synergies. It’s what your cash flow is worth on its own to a financial buyer.
- The market approach tells you where the industry trades. The DCF tells you what your specific cash flow is worth.
- Lower the risk in your cash flow and the discount rate drops. A lower discount rate is a higher multiple.
- If the owner is the business, the buyer is buying a job, not equity. That’s the biggest risk discount there is.
- The capital stack caps your price. Senior debt plus sub debt plus required equity return is the math of every offer.
- When credit tightens, multiples compress. When credit loosens, multiples expand. Pricing tracks debt availability more than interest rates.
- Two companies producing the same EBITDA aren’t worth the same. The one growing into the cash flow stream is worth more.
- Control the narrative or the buyer will. Their narrative is questions you can’t answer, which becomes risk, which becomes price reduction.
- Start five to seven years before you want out. The strategy you pick (ESOP, MBO, third party) sets the runway, not the other way around.
Sound Bites
“When you buy equity, you’re buying the future. You’re buying the future cash flow stream. You’re not getting the past.” (@TBD) — David Diehl
“Valuation is all about risk and the assessment of risk in those cash flow streams.” (@TBD) — David Diehl
“If you don’t control that narrative as a seller, the buyer will. And the buyer’s narrative is going to bring in questions that you can’t answer, which then raises the risk profile.” (@TBD) — David Diehl
“Math solves a lot of problems in this world. That’s just a math equation. That’s not someone being a naysayer. It just is kind of how it works.” (@TBD) — Ryan Tansom
“I just love cash flow.” (@TBD) — David Diehl
About This Episode
David Diehl is the CEO of Prairie Capital Advisors, a middle-market ownership transition and investment banking firm headquartered in Oak Brook, Illinois, with offices in Chicago, Atlanta, Columbus, Cedar Rapids, Kansas City, and Louisville. Prairie has spent 26+ years helping privately held owners transition their businesses through third-party sales, ESOPs, management buyouts, and family transitions, and does roughly 450 valuations a year for owners who aren’t selling but need to know what the company is worth. This is David’s third appearance on the show and the second episode in a three-part series demystifying business valuations, following a foundational conversation with Pat Hobby on how to think about value.
Resources Mentioned
- Prairie Capital Advisors — David’s firm. White papers, webinars, and resources on ownership transition. — prairiecap.com
- Intentional Growth Financial Assessment — 22-question assessment plus a five-video walkthrough with Ryan and Pat on what good looks like. — arkona.io
- Ep. 201 with David Diehl — Mid-pandemic conversation on the state of valuations
- Previous episode in this series — Ryan and Pat Hobby lay down the foundational framework for thinking about value
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 1 — Ownership Goals — Why you need a number to plan against in the first place
- Module 2 — Expand Knowledge — Understanding the three lenses of value before you make decisions
Milestones:
- Milestone 2 — Cash Flow Targets & Sources — The cash flow stream the buyer is pricing
- Milestone 4 — Owner’s Value (DCF) — The intrinsic value lens David walks through
- Milestone 5 — Market Value — The market approach as the external sanity check
- Milestone 6 — Transaction Value — Where strategic synergies and the actual deal show up
Concepts referenced:
- Three Lenses of Value — Owner’s value, market value, transaction value as separate questions
- The Multiple & WACC — How risk in the cash flow translates to the discount rate and the multiple
- Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) — Senior debt, sub debt, and required equity return as the capital stack
- Free Cash Flow — The thing being discounted back to present value
- Normalized EBITDA — The starting point before risk and growth get applied
- Value Gap — The space between what owners think they’re worth and what the math supports
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — The single biggest source of perceived risk in a small business
- Value Growth Plan™ — The deliberate intent David says buyers are actually buying
Related episodes:
- Ep. 309 — Pat Hobby - Demystifying Business Valuations Part 1 — Foundational framework for this three-part series
- Ep. 311 — Demystifying Valuations Part 3 - Transaction Value — How to maximize purchase price in a third-party sale