Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You sit in your chair at the end of another long week and run the same loop again: nobody else can carry this the way I do, but if I don’t get someone else in here, I’m doing this for another decade. That gap between what you actually do every day and what your team can carry is exactly where Mike Frommelt lives. Mike co-founded Strategic Talent Partners (formerly Keystone Search) and has interviewed thousands of C-level executives over 22 years working with privately held companies. I brought him back because I keep watching clients chase the “magic integrator” idea, blow $150K on the wrong hire, and end up 12 months behind where they started. We dug into the real diagnostic: most $30M companies have a $15M leadership team, and the owner is personally making up the difference without realizing it. We got into how to track what you actually do for two or three months before you try to replace it, why strategic thinking is the trait you can’t coach into a linear thinker, the honest base + bonus ranges at $10M and up, and why the smart first hire is usually the constraint seat (sales, ops, or finance), not the president. This is the Module 7 — Leadership Team and Module 9 — Operator Transition work made concrete.
Top 10 Takeaways
- Most $30M companies have a $15M leadership team. You’re the difference, and you don’t even see it.
- You can’t replace what you do until you track it. Two to three months of activity, broken down by function.
- Strategic thinking is largely innate. Linear thinkers make great functional leaders, not great CEOs.
- CEO and President are mostly semantics under $1B. The seat owns the P&L and leads the leaders.
- Your CEO seat has almost no tasks. The job is leading the people who own sales, ops, and finance.
- Big-company “P&L responsibility” often means a sales number while corporate covers ops and finance. Dig before you hire.
- Hire from inside when you can. Most senior teams have doers, not strategists. Be honest about which you have.
- For a $10M company, the top seat runs roughly $225-250K base plus a 30% bonus tied to results.
- Place your next dollar where the constraint is. The president hire often comes after you fix sales or ops.
- Owners who wait too long limit their options. Build the leadership team while you still have runway.
Sound Bites
“How does this even happen? How could you have a $30 million business with a $15 million team? What I realized pretty quickly is it was that owner entrepreneur that was making up the difference. They were really the strategic leader of each of the functional areas.” (@00:11:55) — Mike Frommelt
“That owner can’t just hire a president and then walk away the day they start. There has to be a plan on how things are going to transition.” (@00:15:15) — Mike Frommelt
“When you’re a CEO, your job is to lead people. You need to be that person that’s breaking down silos, getting people working together, getting the most out of your leadership team.” (@00:28:55) — Mike Frommelt
“If you can hire from the inside, that’s the best way to grow your business, because you know that they fit the culture. And it’s a lot less expensive to do it that way.” (@00:44:05) — Mike Frommelt
“You can sell it, take the cash, and go invest that somewhere. Or you can keep it and invest in yourself. What do you know better? Invest in the company that you built. Just make sure you get the right people in there to run it.” (@01:14:00) — Mike Frommelt
About This Episode
Mike Frommelt is the co-founder of Strategic Talent Partners, a national executive search and leadership solutions firm based in Minneapolis. Mike started Keystone Search in 2002 and ran it for 22 years doing exclusively C-level search and consulting for privately held businesses, before merging with Core Talent in April 2024 to form Strategic Talent Partners. He has interviewed thousands of C-level executives and specializes in helping owner-operators recruit and integrate leadership talent aligned with ownership goals. This is Mike’s third appearance on the show. He comes in as the iBD-canon resource on the leadership team and operator transition work.
Resources Mentioned
- Strategic Talent Partners — Mike’s firm. — strategictalentpartners.com
- Mike Frommelt on LinkedIn — linkedin.com/in/mikefrommelt
- Traction by Gino Wickman — Referenced for EOS language around integrator and visionary roles
- The Great Game of Business by Jack Stack — Referenced on open-book management
- The CEO System by Joel Trammell — Referenced for the framing that a CEO has no tasks and is responsible for the P&L through people
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 7 — Leadership Team — Assessing the current team and finding the right top seat
- Module 9 — Operator Transition — Decoupling the owner from day-to-day, which is the heart of this conversation
- Module 8 — Executive Compensation — Pay ranges and bonus structure for the new top seat
Milestones:
- Milestone 19 — Functional Leaders — The sales, ops, and finance leaders sitting under the CEO seat
- Milestone 20 — Leadership Roadmap — The phased plan for building the team
- Milestone 21 — Leadership Development — Developing high-potential people from within before going outside
- Milestone 25 — Operator Transition Plan — The one-to-two-year handoff Mike describes
- Milestone 26 — Recruit Successor — The actual search work Mike’s firm does
Concepts referenced:
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — The founder personally making up the gap between team capability and company size
- Visionary-Integrator Framework — The EOS language Mike and I both push back on as a shortcut
- Owner’s Scorecard™ — The ownership constraints that define what the new top seat actually has to deliver
- Distributable Cash — Why the hire has to pencil before you can pull the trigger
- Normalized EBITDA — The income measure the bonus structure ties to