Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You’re sitting at your desk with a credible offer in front of you. You can run a three-statement model in your sleep. You can build your own DCF. And you still don’t know if it’s the right answer. Tom Nagler walked into our coaching relationship with a Columbia EMBA and decades of valuation chops. He didn’t need help with the math. He needed help sitting with the decision. We walked the whole arc on this one: Tom’s dad started Natech Plastics in 1998; Tom joined a year later instead of moving to Tokyo; he bought his dad’s final shares in 2014, lost his dad in 2016, and turned down two credible acquisition offers before saying yes to the strategic merger that closed in July 2023. The patterns inside the arc are where the gold lives: the family-business trust that’s hard to replicate anywhere else, the years he hired on skill before he learned to hire on values, the activity-based costing class that exposed how badly he was under-pricing short jobs, and the moment he realized that whatever he chose, six months later he’d second-guess it. The line that lands at the end is the one most owners need to hear: a lot of the suffering is optional.
Top 10 Takeaways
- Trust is the family business edge. Even when you and dad go head-to-head, the trust question is off the table.
- A verbal exit deal on your dad’s yellow pad isn’t an exit plan. Get the Milestone 25 — Operator Transition Plan on paper.
- Activity-based costing usually reveals you over-price long jobs and badly under-price short ones.
- The reward for success in a capital-intensive business is needing more capital. That’s just the deal.
- Step resources mean cash and capacity arrive on different schedules. Knowing the pattern lets your decisions breathe.
- Hiring on skill captures the next 30 days. Hiring on values compounds for the next decade.
- Real values are the behaviors you hold to even when they cost you economically and nobody’s looking.
- Saying no to a credible offer because fear is driving the yes is itself the right answer.
- The right buyer survives three filters: what the deal means to you, your team, and your clients.
- Knowing the valuation cold doesn’t tell you whether to sell. That decision lives somewhere else.
Sound Bites
“I used to say my dad gave me a compliment once back in 1986.” (@00:13:08) — Tom Nagler
“The values are timeless enduring principles. They are behaviors that we hold to whether or not they’re an economic disadvantage to us.” (@00:35:50) — Tom Nagler
“The reward for success in a capital-intensive business is you need to go get more. You need to invest more capital. That’s your reward, man.” (@00:43:31) — Tom Nagler
“I was, like for more than a decade, Ryan, I was like one wrong decision away from financial ruin. The value of getting out from under that is priceless.” (@01:46:51) — Tom Nagler
“A lot of the pain is optional. A lot of the suffering is optional.” (@01:53:42) — Tom Nagler
About This Episode
Tom Nagler ran Natech Plastics, the contract manufacturing firm his father founded on Long Island in 1998, for over two decades. He earned his Executive MBA from Columbia Business School and built deep expertise in valuation, activity-based costing, and DCF modeling — uncommon for a small-business operator. After buying out his father in 2014, navigating his dad’s passing in 2016, and turning down two credible acquisition offers (one Japanese in 2017, one German in the same window), Tom sold Natech to a German PE-backed strategic in July 2023. He worked alongside Ryan during the run-up to the decision, walking through the personal waterfall, the three-statement model, and the deal structure. He left the acquirer’s payroll in April 2025 and is now redeploying capital and time into operating businesses, coaching, and the great American experience of entrepreneurship.
Resources Mentioned
- Natech Plastics — Tom’s former company. Contract injection molder focused on the medical/diagnostic markets.
- Columbia Business School EMBA — Where Tom built his valuation, ABC costing, and operations finance toolkit.
- Tom Nagler on LinkedIn — Best place to reach him for collaboration on creative work with business owners.
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 1 — Ownership Goals — The personal waterfall, the “what does my ideal life cost” question Tom worked through
- Module 4 — Sustainable Financials — Three-statement model, activity-based costing, capital-intensive cash flow
- Module 7 — Leadership Team — The values-based hiring shift that took Tom a decade to learn
- Module 9 — Operator Transition — The actual sale and post-sale chapter
Milestones inside Operator Transition and Sustainable Financials:
- Milestone 2 — Cash Flow Targets & Sources — Tom’s personal waterfall: what does my ideal life cost
- Milestone 4 — Owner’s Value (DCF) — Tom built his own DCF; this is the discipline he had cold
- Milestone 5 — Market Value — The football field across credible buyer types
- Milestone 6 — Transaction Value — The actual deal Tom negotiated
- Milestone 16 — Target Gross Margins — Where ABC costing exposes the under-priced short jobs
- Milestone 25 — Operator Transition Plan — Yellow pad to written plan, the gap most family businesses live in
Concepts referenced:
- Three-Statement Model — The discipline Tom had clean before he ever met me
- Three Lenses of Value — Owner utility, market value, transaction value (the framework for sitting with the decision)
- The Multiple & WACC — The math Tom knew cold and still couldn’t decide on
- Free Cash Flow — What the buyer is actually paying for
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — Why “once the sale happens, you’re an employee” hits so hard
- Capital Allocator — Tom’s next chapter, deploying liquidity into operating businesses
- Independence by Design™ — The container for owner-driven decisions like this one