Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You’re standing in front of your team telling them there’s no profit share this month because you chased a shiny object and lost. That’s the moment Sherry Deutschmann realized it was time to sell LetterLogic. She had built the company from a basement door laid across two Goodwill filing cabinets into a $40M Inc 5000 mainstay (eleven straight years on the list), pricing 10% above the market in a commoditized industry because her culture did the selling for her. 10% of profits split evenly every month, $16/hour minimum wage in a $7.25 state, down-payment gifts that put 19 employees into their first homes. In this conversation, we got into how she actually afforded all of it (her answer: she couldn’t afford not to), the twice-a-week mini valuations her interim COO ran with the leadership team that completely changed how they made decisions, the customer pricing calls she made herself CEO-to-CEO without losing a single account, and the part nobody talks about — what it actually feels like to sell to a PE firm, watch them kill the profit-share model six months later, and realize the goals of private equity aren’t evil, they’re just not yours.
Watch on YouTube
## Top 10 Takeaways- If your team doesn’t know how the company makes money, they can’t change behavior to protect it.
- Profit share split evenly tells every seat their job matters as much as every other seat.
- A fair living wage is calculated from the bottom up: can your two lowest-paid people build a life on it?
- Your culture is your cheapest marketing channel and your most defensible pricing power.
- Mini valuations every Monday and Thursday change what your leadership team optimizes for in real time.
- Your biggest customers are often your least profitable. Raise the rate yourself, CEO to CEO.
- The right time to sell is when the bottom line is outgrowing the top line on a trailing-twelve basis.
- Cultural fit at the buyer level is a wish, not a control. Earnouts and board seats don’t fix it.
- Staying on as a minority shareholder after the sale is the slowest, most painful version of selling.
- The happiest exited owners are the ones who walked all the way out on close day.
Sound Bites
“We weren’t successful in spite of the crazy benefits that we provided. We were only successful because of it.” (@00:15:00) — Sherry Deutschmann
“You would think that a company valuation can’t change much from a Thursday to a Monday. But if you lose a big customer it can change a lot, or if you add a good-sized customer the valuation can change a lot. And it did. And so it made all of us aware of what was driving the value of the company and changed our behavior too.” (@00:21:42) — Sherry Deutschmann
“I went into every single phone call knowing that I might lose the customer, but that our company was better off not having this customer if they weren’t profitable.” (@00:23:45) — Sherry Deutschmann
“It’s not that the new parent doesn’t love the child the same way. It’s that they love him differently.” (@00:49:57) — Sherry Deutschmann
About This Episode
Sherry Deutschmann is the founder of LetterLogic, a Nashville-based healthcare patient statement company she started in her basement in January 2002 and grew to $40M in revenue and 54 employees before selling to a private equity firm in 2016. LetterLogic appeared on the Inc 5000 list for eleven consecutive years. After the sale Sherry founded BrainTrust, an angel investment and mentorship platform for women entrepreneurs, and is the author of Lunch with Lucy. She talks with Ryan about the employee-first operating model that produced her premium pricing, the prep work that got the company sale-ready, and what she’d do differently if she had the deal to do over.
Resources Mentioned
- Finish Big by Bo Burlingham — Referenced for knowing who you are, what you want from your business, and why before you sell
- Mike Nolan, Empire Business Brokers (Raleigh, NC) — The broker who ran twice-weekly mini valuations with Sherry’s leadership team
- Brad Stevens — The interim COO Sherry hired to diagnose why the company was losing money
- EO (Entrepreneurs’ Organization) — Where Sherry found support and identity after the sale
- Email: sherry@sherrydeutschmann.com
- LinkedIn: Sherry Deutschmann
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 1 — Ownership Goals — Knowing what enough looks like before you sit at the table
- Module 7 — Leadership Team — The team that takes care of the customer is the asset being sold
Milestones:
- Milestone 3 — Net Worth & Valuation Targets — The trailing-twelve picture that told Sherry it was time
- Milestone 8 — Quarterly Boardroom Rhythm — Sherry’s twice-weekly mini valuations as an early version of the boardroom discipline
- Milestone 16 — Target Gross Margins — Why raising rates on the biggest accounts didn’t lose them
- Milestone 21 — Leadership Development — The leadership team that ran the sale prep alongside her
- Milestone 22 — Company Bonus Pool — Profit share as the operating accountability mechanism
Concepts referenced:
- Normalized EBITDA — The trailing-twelve number the buyers were pricing
- The Multiple & WACC — Why the bottom-line trajectory mattered more than the top
- Value Gap — Pricing 10% above the market because the culture justified it
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — Identity loss when the company is no longer yours