Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
You wake up at 52, you still own the customer relationships, you’re still the only person making operating decisions, and you tell yourself this is just what running your own business looks like. It isn’t. It’s a choice you keep making by not making the other one. Mike Frommelt has spent 30 years and run somewhere north of 12,000 interviews helping owners hire the president who actually decouples them from the day-to-day. He’s the founder of Keystone Search and was featured in Gino Wickman’s Rocket Fuel. We got into where you actually start (inventorying everything you do that you don’t even realize you’re doing), why your CFO knowing every detail of the business doesn’t make them your successor, why hiring up beats hiring down, how to structure phantom stock so you’re not handing over equity on what you already built, and why most owners who claim they can’t afford a president are really telling you they haven’t decided what they want from the business. Including a family-business scenario where the president’s job is to develop the next-gen kid before stepping out themselves.
Watch on YouTube
## Top 10 Takeaways- Your role and your ownership are two separate seats. Most owners hold both because nobody told them they don’t have to.
- Before you hire anyone, inventory what you actually do all day. After twenty years in, you can’t see half of it.
- Hire someone who’s already seen where you want to go. A $20M operator running your $20M company stalls you out.
- Your CFO knowing every detail of the business doesn’t make them your successor. Operating knowledge isn’t strategic capability.
- Stop framing the president hire as compensation. Frame it as opportunity cost. The return is value, not salary.
- Don’t give equity on what you already built. Tie Module 8 — Executive Compensation to the value created after they walk in.
- Phantom stock and SAR plans pay nothing if no value gets created. Real equity has to be unwound when it doesn’t work.
- Roll the long-term comp plan across your whole leadership team, not just the new president. They’re the ones executing.
- Industry experience matters less than mental agility and core values. A few months of ramp beats years of bad behavior.
- If you don’t have a plan for the business, no strong president will join you. They’re already winning somewhere else.
Sound Bites
“This is not about putting yourself out to pasture.” (@00:10:02) — Ryan Tansom
“If you have too much operational and you leave the magic of the visionary aside, things can implode.” (@00:10:37) — Ryan Tansom
“You shouldn’t be bringing somebody in from the outside and giving them equity on what you built. You only want to give them a piece of the pie on what they build.” (@00:41:57) — Mike Frommelt
“I would trade that every day for someone who’s got the right mental agility, the right intelligence, the right leadership skills and the right core values. I’d live with a few extra months of them learning the industry rather than trying to find somebody that comes in hitting the ground running on the industry.” (@00:39:02) — Mike Frommelt
“When you do the planning and the hard work of evaluating where you are, where you want to go, putting a plan together, all of a sudden other options open up.” (@00:49:35) — Mike Frommelt
About This Episode
Mike Frommelt is the co-founder and CEO of Keystone Search, an executive recruiting firm focused exclusively on privately held companies in the $10M to $300M revenue range. He has 30+ years in executive search and has been featured in Gino Wickman’s Rocket Fuel for his work helping owners hire their replacements, the integrators and presidents who let founders step out of the day-to-day. Mike specializes in two niches: ESOP-owned companies and businesses running EOS/Traction. He’s an active member of the ESOP Association and the National Center for Employee Ownership, and has run EOS inside Keystone for nearly a decade.
Resources Mentioned
- Keystone Search — Mike’s executive recruiting firm specializing in privately held companies, ESOPs, and EOS-run businesses.
- Rocket Fuel by Gino Wickman & Mark C. Winters — Mike is featured for his work on Visionary/Integrator hires.
- EOS / Traction by Gino Wickman — Referenced throughout for the Visionary-Integrator language.
- The Infinite Game by Simon Sinek — Ryan references the CEO/CFO yin-and-yang section.
- The Great Game of Business by Jack Stack — Referenced as a culture and ownership influence.
- Small Giants by Bo Burlingham — Referenced in the same vein.
- The ESOP Association & National Center for Employee Ownership — Mike’s professional affiliations.
- Vistage / EO — Peer group/Roundtable options for developing internal leaders before transition.
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 7 — Leadership Team — Where the executive team gets built before any president walks in
- Module 8 — Executive Compensation — Phantom stock, SAR, and deferred comp tied to value growth, not just salary
- Module 9 — Operator Transition — Recruiting your successor and passing the baton
Milestones inside Module 8 and Module 9:
- Milestone 22 — Company Bonus Pool — The base of the comp architecture before any long-term plan
- Milestone 24 — Long-Term Value Plan — Phantom stock/SAR plans tied to the value delta the new hire creates
- Milestone 25 — Operator Transition Plan — The plan that needs to exist before any search begins
- Milestone 26 — Recruit Successor — The actual president/integrator search Mike does for a living
- Milestone 27 — Integrate & Pass the Baton — Onboarding, tribal knowledge transfer, and the runway to exit the seat
Concepts referenced:
- Visionary-Integrator Framework — The EOS language Mike works inside; not 100% pure on either side, more like 70/30
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — Why owners can’t even see what they actually do all day
- The Four Value Levers — Where the president actually moves the business after they walk in
- Independence by Design™ — The full framework that separates the role from the ownership