Subscribe: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeartRadio · Pandora · RSS
Episode Summary
Your top performers are stacked with three jobs each. Comp got built around credit card points and a grill instead of outcomes. Bonuses get delayed every year and nobody quite knows why their number landed where it landed. That’s the mess Jennifer Davis walked into at Davisware before she spent three years rebuilding the whole thing from mission statement down to the bonus formula. I had her back on because the way she rebuilt her comp structure is the cleanest example I’ve heard of connecting Module 1 — Ownership Goals to org chart, to position descriptions, to KPIs, to the bonus pool, with no surprises at the end of the year. We got into why the first year of the project never touches comp at all. Why every position description gets written by the person doing the job first. Why 80% of the bonus comes from company goals and the remaining 20% gets split, with a slice tied to personal goals like fitness and family. And why the conversation about money in her business basically disappeared once the financials, the scorecard, and the Milestone 23 — Short-Term Incentive Plan all rolled out of the same mission. Real numbers, real mistakes, and the honest version of how long it actually takes.
Top 10 Takeaways
- Resentment is the gap between expectations and reality. Comp is where that gap shows up first.
- Your business has three real assets: your brand, your team, your customers. Everything else is just the vehicle.
- Before you touch comp, forgive yourself for the mess. Every growing company has weird historical pay decisions.
- Rebuilding comp is a three-year project. Decide that up front or you’ll be two years late on a one-year plan.
- Year one is mission, vision, position descriptions, and org chart. You don’t touch a single bonus number.
- Have employees write their own position descriptions first. They’ll write tasks, and that tells you they’ve never been given outcomes.
- Lock the bonus pool to a percent of margin, not a fixed dollar amount, with a floor and a multiplier above target.
- Split the bonus 80/20: company goals first, then individual. Then split the individual 75/25 with personal goals included.
- Every company goal needs revenue, EBITDA, cash, ENPS, and NPS in it. Brand, team, customers, in that order of weight.
- If you raise comp without raising clarity, you double the friction when you hire the next person.
Sound Bites
“When you eliminate ambiguity from any relationship, from any conversation, you eliminate the friction. Comp is why people come to work.” (@TBD) — Jennifer Davis
“The friction isn’t that the bonus was delayed. The friction is that employees were surprised by it.” (@TBD) — Jennifer Davis
“You have three assets that matter: your brand, your culture and people, and your customers. Frame everything you do around those three and you will find success.” (@TBD) — Jennifer Davis
“Resentment and unhappiness is the gap between expectations and reality.” (@TBD) — Ryan Tansom
“Just because you don’t have the starting position doesn’t mean you’re on a different team. If you don’t believe you’re on the same team as the starting pitcher, you’re actually on the wrong team.” (@TBD) — Jennifer Davis
About This Episode
Jennifer Davis is the former co-owner of Davisware, a vertical software company she and her husband Dan built over more than three decades before selling the majority to private equity. Across that run she rebuilt the company’s compensation structure from the ground up, lifting ENPS and NPS scores so far above industry standard the acquirer ordered outside validation because they didn’t believe the numbers. She now runs a portfolio of consulting, leadership training, and women’s retreat work through B Exponential, authored Living Exponentially, and is launching a campaign for U.S. Congress in Illinois District 8. This is her second appearance on the show.
Resources Mentioned
- Jennifer Davis — Consulting, leadership training, and B Exponential. — jenniferedavis.com
- Living Exponentially by Jennifer Davis — Available at jenniferedavis.com
- The Road Less Stupid by Keith Cunningham — Referenced in the cold open
- RAGBRAI — The Register’s Annual Great Bike Ride Across Iowa, referenced for context on Jennifer’s recent ride
- Conscious Capitalism / Small Giants — Referenced as the philosophical lineage Ryan ties this conversation to
Connections
Phase + Module:
- Module 8 — Executive Compensation — The whole episode lives here: comp tied to goals tied to position descriptions tied to mission
- Module 3 — Owner’s Playbook — Mission, vision, org chart, and the playbook discipline that has to exist before comp gets touched
- Module 7 — Leadership Team — Position descriptions as the front door to functional leadership
Milestones:
- Milestone 23 — Short-Term Incentive Plan — The 80/20 split, the percent-of-margin formula, the floor and multiplier
- Milestone 22 — Company Bonus Pool — Pool sized to margin, not fixed dollars
- Milestone 20 — Leadership Roadmap — Expanding the leadership team to own the mission/vision work
- Milestone 17 — Operational KPIs — Visibility rule: if you won’t share the data, you can’t tie comp to it
Concepts referenced:
- Normalized EBITDA — One of the five elements baked into every company goal
- Owner’s Scorecard™ — Revenue, EBITDA, cash, ENPS, NPS as the standing measurement set
- The Owner-Operator Trap™ — Why owners default to stacking A-players with more hats instead of fixing the structure
- Theory of Constraints — Cultural friction as the hidden constraint that comp clarity removes
- Quarterly Boardroom Rhythm™ — Where the annual goal-setting and mid-year check-in cadence lives
Related episodes:
- Ep. 452 — Jennifer Davis - The First Conversation — Jennifer’s first appearance, the backstory and the Davisware build
- Ep. 492 — Ryan Tansom - How to Analyze Your Margins and Gross Profit — The margin chart that the bonus pool sits inside